Acrylic Pins vs Enamel Pins: Which Should You Order?
Rafik FaragShare
We make acrylic pins. We don't make enamel pins. So read this knowing where we stand, and then decide for yourself. Both are good products. They're just good at different things, and most of the people who email us asking for "enamel pins" actually want something an acrylic pin does better. Some don't. Here's how to tell.
How an enamel pin is made
An enamel pin is metal. Your design is cut into a steel mould, the mould stamps a metal blank (usually iron or a zinc alloy), and the raised metal lines become the outline of your artwork. Colour is enamel paste filled into the spaces between those lines, one colour per space. Soft enamel leaves the colour slightly recessed, so you can feel the lines. Hard enamel is filled higher and polished flat. Then the metal is plated (gold, silver, black), the post is soldered on, and the pin is finished.
That process has consequences. Every colour has to be a solid, flat fill, separated from the next colour by a metal line. No gradients, no photos, no soft shading. Small text turns into a blob. The mould costs money, so most makers charge a setup fee and set a minimum, commonly 50 or 100 pins. And because most enamel pins are made overseas, two to four weeks is a normal wait.
How an acrylic pin is made
An acrylic pin is printed. We print your artwork straight onto clear acrylic in three passes: colour, then white, then colour again. The white layer in the middle is what makes the colours solid instead of see-through. Then we cut the pin to the outline of your design, leaving a 0.0625" clear edge, glue the post to the back with UV adhesive and add a butterfly clutch. No mould, no setup fee, no plating.
Because it's printed, anything you can put in a file, we can put on a pin. Gradients. Photographs. A 40-colour illustration. Text down to the point where it stops being legible, which on a 1.5" pin is smaller than you'd think. Minimum order is 10, and you can put up to four designs in one order and split the quantity between them. Production is 3 to 5 business days after you approve the proof, in North York, Toronto.
What each one is good at
Enamel pins have a weight and a shine that people associate with "a real pin." Collectors like them. A metal-lined logo with two or three flat colours looks great in enamel, and the surface scratches rather than cracks. If your design is simple and bold, you want a hundred or more of one design, and you can wait a few weeks, enamel is a fine choice.
Acrylic pins win when the artwork matters. An illustrator's character with shading. A photo. A logo with a gradient. A design with fine lines and small lettering. They're light, so they sit flat on a lanyard or a thin jacket. They start at 10 pieces, so you can test a design before committing to 200. And they ship in days.
The honest trade-off: an acrylic pin is a sheet of acrylic. Dropped on concrete or sat on, it can crack where a metal pin would just scratch. In normal wear, on a bag, a jacket or a lanyard, that doesn't come up. The other thing to know is the post: it's glued to the back, so the artwork needs about 0.35" of solid area behind it. A very thin, tall shape leaves the post showing. We flag that on the proof.
What acrylic pins cost
Live prices as of October 30, 2026, before tax, any shape, up to four designs per order:
- 1" × 1": 50 for $75.84 ($1.52 each), 100 for $102.30 ($1.02 each), 500 for $471.68 (94¢ each)
- 1.5" × 1.5", the size most people order: 10 for $60.38, 50 for $115.09 ($2.30 each), 100 for $218.86 ($2.19 each)
- 2" × 2": 50 for $196.22 ($3.92 each), 100 for $382.38 ($3.82 each)
Free shipping on orders over $100 to Canada and the US (US tariffs, if any, are charged on delivery), or pick up in North York.
I haven't put enamel prices beside those, because enamel pricing depends on the mould, the plating, the number of colours and the vendor, and a number pulled from one website would be wrong for the next. Get a real quote for your design and compare it to the numbers above.
So which one?
Pick enamel if your design is a flat-colour logo, you want the metal feel, you need 100 or more of one design, and the date isn't close.
Pick acrylic if your artwork has shading, photos, gradients or fine detail, if you want to start at 10, if you need four designs in one order, or if the event is next week.
If you're still not sure, send us the artwork. If it would print badly as an acrylic pin, we'll say so at the proof stage before anything is made.
Questions we get
Can you make enamel pins? No. We print acrylic pins in Toronto and we don't outsource metal pins.
Are acrylic pins durable? In normal wear, yes. The ink is UV-cured hard onto the acrylic, so it doesn't rub off. They can crack under a hard impact, where metal would dent or scratch.
Can I get the back printed? The front is the printed side. The back carries the post and clutch.
Do you have a minimum? 10 pins. Up to four designs in the same order, split however you like.
How long does it take? A digital proof usually within 24 hours, then 3 to 5 business days of production after you approve it.
Order custom acrylic pins, or see the whole acrylic line: keychains, charms and standees are made the same way.
Related reading: How to Design an Acrylic Keychain So It Prints Well · What Is a Custom Acrylic Keychain?
